Colleen Carey

A true “Island Gal” at heart, Colleen Carey combines her deep-rooted passion for island living with an extensive knowledge of Bahamian culture to expertly guide clients in selling or finding their perfect home—whether in Harbour Island, Eleuthera, Spanish Wells, or anywhere in The Bahamas. As a third-generation real estate professional, Colleen has an innate understanding of Bahamian market trends and history; she leverages this expertise to help her clients navigate their real estate journey seamlessly, make informed investment decisions, and maximize their returns.

Colleen’s core intention is to create value for her clients, whether they are buying or selling. She is deeply committed to honesty, connection, integrity, and perseverance—always keeping her clients’ best interests at heart. She genuinely enjoys the process of listening and getting to know each client on a personal level, ensuring that their unique needs and aspirations are met.

Her entrepreneurial background and experience in marketing have shaped her ability to think strategically and creatively. She brings a visionary approach to real estate, particularly in showcasing properties at their highest potential. From understanding the essence of a home to staging and collaborating with media professionals, Colleen thrives in the creative process of curating the perfect 'luxury' presentation for every listing.

A former U.S. National Team rugby player and Bahamian National Team soccer player, Colleen applies the same discipline, drive, and goal-oriented mindset to real estate that she did to competitive sports. With a Bachelor of Arts in Anthropology and a minor in History, she values cultural and global connections, allowing her to build meaningful relationships with clients from around the world.

Beyond real estate, Colleen is an avid traveler who enjoys practicing and teaching yoga, freediving, spearfishing, fitness, reading, writing, photography, and, most importantly, spending quality time with her husband and children.

Whether you're seeking the perfect island retreat or looking to maximize the value of your property, Colleen’s expertise, dedication, and creative vision make her an invaluable partner in your real estate journey.